Thursday, February 12, 2009

Pueblo and Southeastern Illinois presbyteries

Another presbytery has shifted in favor of equality -- in this case it's a presbytery that we'd hope would shift pro-LGBT this year.

Southeastern Illinois:
2001-2 01-A: 69 yes, 77 no --> 47.3% YES
2009 08-B: 68 yes, 56 no --> 54.8% YES

So it's close to an 8% pro-LGBT shift, and this presbytery votes YES on equality this year. Very nice.

Also, in the past day or two Pueblo Presbytery voted. Although this was another "very unlikely to shift to yes" presbytery, the percentage pro-equality shift is excellent:

Pueblo:
2001-2 01-A: 23 yes, 77 no --> 23% YES
2009 08-B: 27 yes, 54 no --> 33% YES

This is one of just a few presbyteries, under 30% previous pro-equality support, to shift in a pro-equality direction -- in this case by a significant percentage.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Four more recent presbytery votes: one flip, one "almost"

Votes continue to come in as more presbyteries vote.  Here are the latest numbers.

Blackhawk:
2001-2 01-A: 48 yes, 90 no --> 35% YES
2009 08-B: 57 yes, 73 no --> 44% YES

A strong 9% pro-equality shift from Blackhawk, again confirming the trend that presbyteries with over 30% previous pro-equality support are mostly shifting pro-LGBT. Blackhawk now moves into "candidate swing presbytery" territory with that 44% pro-equality support level.


Chicago:
2001-2 01-A: 247 yes, 170 no --> 59% YES
2009 08-B: 204 yes, 69 no --> 75% YES

This is a strong 16% pro-LGBT shift here from Chicago. The dropoff in total votes seems rather large -- that's 144 fewer votes in 2009 than in 2002. I'm not sure if that tells us anything or not.


Cimarron:
2001-2 01-A: 16 yes, 20 no --> 44.4% YES
2009 08-B: 19 yes, 16 no --> 54.3% YES

Cimarron flips from anti-equality to pro-equality! This was definitely one of those "every vote counts" situations, as was the next in our list...


Cincinnati:
2001-2 01-A: 95 yes, 113 no --> 45.7% YES
2009 08-B: 83 yes, 83 no --> 50.0% YES (but not sufficient to pass)

This is something of a disappointment and presumably was frustrating for LGBT supporters in Cincinnati, to have the vote come out exactly split like this. An exact tie unfortunately isn't sufficient to pass an overture, so this gets recorded as a "no" vote on 08-B from Cincinnati presbytery. We ideally should have been able to flip this presbytery pro-equality this year, since it was already in the mid-40's, but we missed it by 1 vote. Somewhere out there, some More Light supporter in Cincinnati is probably losing sleep over why they decided to skip the presbytery meeting this week. The lesson to take here is probably "don't be the person who skips the presbytery meeting - it could end up as a tie!"

However it's still a 4% pro-equality shift, so we'll get there eventually.

How many presbyteries? The importance of voting trends

On a mailing list, somebody asked:

> how many non-supportive presbyteries need to flip to PRO for Amendment 08B to pass?

My math says that 46 presbyteries voted "yes" on 01-A in 2001-2, so it would take an additional 41 presbyteries shifting votes from "no" or "no action" to "yes" to get the necessary 87 votes to pass 08-B.

That's a very difficult voting cliff to scale in just 7 years, which is one reason why I feel it's important to track not just the resulting presbytery vote totals, but the percentage shifts within each presbytery.

The "no" votes start from a very strong base -- there are simply a lot of presbyteries that voted under 35% for equality in 2001-2, and it's very difficult to move from 35% equality support to 51% support in 7 years. The good news is that we're seeing a lot of the low-30's presbyteries become high-30's or even low-40's in terms of pro-equality support, which makes them easier to get to 51% if there needs to be a "next time".

My hope is that we'll at least make it to >50% of all individual presbytery voters voting "yes", even if 08-B doesn't make it. That would be the equivalent of "winning the popular vote but losing the electoral college vote" and would be a huge symbolic victory for equality (don't discount the value of symbolism). So it's important for everybody to work on "yes" voter turnout and persuasion no matter where you are.

Monday, February 9, 2009

Two more vote updates from the past weekend

We have two more presbytery vote updates from the past weekend.  Both are "no" votes, however both of these were expected, and again the trends look good.

Flint River:
2001-2 01-A: 20 yes, 71 no --> 22% YES
2009 08-B: 27 yes, 47 no --> 36.5% YES

This is one of the first presbyteries to break with the trend of "under-30% presbyteries are shifting anti-gay". Here we have nearly a 15% PRO-equality shift in a traditionally very anti-LGBT presbytery.

Flint River's vote shows that it IS possible to move the vote pro-equality even in the difficult presbyteries. Even better is that the shift doesn't result entirely from fewer people voting "no" -- there was also a significant increase in the "yes" vote count even though the total number of people voting at presbytery declined from 2001-2.

So I wouldn't place any bets on a "yes to delete B" vote from Flint River any time soon, but this year's vote is a very positive trend.



Wyoming:
2001-2 01-A: voice vote "no" --> no percentage available
2009 08-B: 18 yes, 38 no --> 32% YES

Here we have our second "voice 'no' vote in 2001-2" presbytery to take its vote. Unlike East Tennessee, Wyoming didn't flip pro-LGBT. However, even the fact that the presbytery shifted from taking a voice vote to taking a counted vote suggests to me that there's a pro-LGBT trend. If a vote is going to be really painfully lopsided, you can take it via voice, but Wyoming didn't do that this year.

Wyoming has now come in at over 30% pro-LGBT in the vote, so if my rule of thumb holds that says ">30% pro-equality means it will trend more pro-equality", then over time Wyoming should improve gradually in its pro-LGBT voting patterns.


So again even though both of these are "no" votes, the trends favor equality for both of these presbyteries.

Sunday, February 8, 2009

Weekend voting wrapup - a good weekend for equality

I've now updated the tracking and percent-shift spreadsheet with the known results of this weekend's votes.

Scorecard for the weekend:
- 7 presbyteries voted
- 0 of these fell into my definition of "swing presbyteries" that I speculated could change their vote this year.
- 6 trended pro-LGBT compared to 2001-2.
- 1 flipped from voting anti-equality to voting pro-equality.
- Total: 3 "yes" votes, 4 "no" votes on 08-B. I would have predicted 2 "yes", 5 "no" if you had asked me in advance.

So this was a good weekend for equality.

As Michael Adee recently mentioned on the Morelightpresbyterians Yahoogroups list, we had another presbytery flip to pro-equality this weekend: East Tennessee. What's interesting about this presbytery is that in 2001-2 it took a voice vote on delete-b overture 01-A. I had been assuming that the "voice vote NO" presbyteries were probably so anti-LGBT that they would never flip pro-equality this year. East Tennessee now tells us that I was wrong, which is good.

There are 11 other presbyteries that took voice "no" votes on 01-A in 2001-2 (see the spreadsheet and look for "VOICE"), so it will be interesting to see if any of these might flip pro-LGBT this year.

Here's a summary of the percentage shifts from this weekend's votes, plus some comments:

East Tennessee
2001-2 01-A: voice vote no --> no percentage available
2009 08-B: 81 yes, 66 no --> 55.1% YES

Great job in East Tennessee to everybody working on More Light concerns there. This presbytery's voting history has been consistently anti-LGBT in the past, so to bring in the vote at a solid 55% pro-equality is a very strong positive shift.


New Covenant
2001-2 01-A: 120 yes, 214 no --> 36% YES
2009 08-B: 119 yes, 171 no --> 41% YES (5% pro-LGBT shift)

This isn't as spectacular a pro-LGBT shift as some of the mid-30%-support presbyteries have shown, however 5% is pretty solid. Every presbytery that shifts into the 40's with a "yes" vote becomes a more likely target swing presbytery in case we need to go through this delete-B exercise again in a few years.


The Peaks
2001-2 01-A: 77 yes, 166 no --> 32% YES
2009 08-B: 74 yes, 136 no --> 35% YES (3% pro-LGBT shift)

This 3% shift stays consistent with my working theory that presbyteries with previous votes slightly over 30% pro-equality are slowly shifting in the pro-equality direction.


Plains and Peaks
2001-2 01-A: 60 yes, 91 no --> 39.7% YES
2009 08-B: 41 yes, 60 no --> 40.6% YES (1% pro-LGBT shift)

Nothing spectacular, but I'll gladly take a 1% pro-LGBT shift even though it's pretty much statistical noise. The reduction in total voters is interesting here -- 151 people in 2001-2 vs. 101 people in 2009. Many presbyteries show similar trends in the total number of voters.


Prospect Hill
2001-2 01-A: 24 yes, 62 no --> 28% YES
2009 08-B: 12 yes, 63 no --> 16% YES (12% anti-LGBT shift, ouch)

This 12% shift in the anti-LGBT direction is consistent with my working theory that many presbyteries under 30% previous support are trending anti-equality in their votes. This is the largest anti-LGBT percentage shift we've seen so far. Checking my presbytery map, I see that Prospect Hill is in northwest Iowa plus a tiny bit of Nebraska, which doesn't particularly strike me as an area that I'd "expect" to trend anti-gay, however I don't live there so I don't know.


Redwoods
2001-2 01-A: 102 yes, 49 no --> 67.5% YES
2009 08-B: 102 yes, 28 no --> 78.5% YES (11% pro-LGBT shift)

Nice job to everybody in Redwoods for demonstrating that a presbytery already with a 2/3 pro-LGBT voting record can give us an additional 11% pro-LGBT shift.


Winnebago
2001-2 01-A: 50 yes, 20 no --> 71.4% YES
2009 08-B: 55 yes, 20 no --> 73.3% YES (2% pro-LGBT shift)

And to round them out, a >70% pro-LGBT presbytery shows that you're not done with the work of trending pro-equality until it's 100% YES. :-)

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Excellent pro-LGBT shift from St. Andrew presbytery

It appears that St. Andrew Presbytery voted on 08-B very recently, and although 08-B didn't pass there, the pro-LGBT shift is very high:

2001-2 01-A: 11 yes, 86 no --> 11.3% YES
2009 08-B: 30 yes, 50 no --> 37.5% YES

This is a 26% pro-LGBT shift in just 7 years, the largest shift we've seen in any presbytery so far. They nearly tripled the number of people voting for equality. And it's one of a few presbyteries with previous LGBT support under 30% which has shifted in a pro-LGBT direction. Many of the under-30% presbyteries have been shifting anti-LGBT when we compare 2001-2 to 2009.

So in terms of "largest pro-LGBT shift in a presbytery vote", Saint Andrew is presently in the lead. Nice job.

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Lake Huron Presbytery flips pro-LGBT

For the second time in just a few days, a presbytery which previously voted anti-LGBT in 2001-2 has flipped its vote and has now voted pro-equality.

Lake Huron stats:
2001-2 01-A: 42 yes, 64 no --> 39.6% YES
2009 08-B: 43 yes, 32 no --> 57.3% YES

This is an 18% pro-LGBT shift in just 7 years, which is fantastic. And it's also in another "under 40%" presbytery that I wouldn't have expected to flip very easily this year.

If you're working in a presbytery and you aren't sure what to do to advocate for yes-on-08-B, maybe get on the phone to a pro-LGBT supporter at these presbyteries (Western North Carolina and now Lake Huron, both of which flipped) and ask them for tips. But first download and read MLP's "yes" resource kit from mlp.org, of course.